<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
    <teiHeader>
        <fileDesc>
            <titleStmt>
                <title level="a">Remarks occasioned by Mr. Moore&#8217;s Life of Lord Byron</title>
                <title level="j">Literary Gazette</title>
                <author key="LyByron">Lady Byron</author>
                <respStmt>
                    <resp> Markup and editing by </resp>
                    <name> David Hill Radcliffe </name>
                </respStmt>
            </titleStmt>
            <editionStmt>
                <edition n="1"> Completed <date n="2011-11"> November 2011 </date>
                </edition>
            </editionStmt>
            <extent/>
            <publicationStmt>
                <idno rend="doc.php">LyByron.1830.Moore</idno>
                <publisher> Center for Applied Technologies in the Humanities </publisher>
                <pubPlace> Virginia Tech </pubPlace>
                <availability status="restricted">
                    <p>Published under Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported
                        License</p>
                </availability>
            </publicationStmt>
            <seriesStmt>
                <p>Lord Byron and his Times: http://lordbyron.org</p>
            </seriesStmt>
            <sourceDesc>
                <bibl>
                    <author key="LyByron">Lady Byron</author>
                    <title level="a">Remarks occasioned by Mr. Moore&#8217;s Notices of Lord Byron&#8217;s
                        Life</title>
                    <title level="j" key="LiteraryGaz">Literary Gazette</title>
                    <pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
                    <date when="1830-03-20">20 March 1830</date>
                    <biblScope type="issue">687</biblScope>
                    <biblScope type="pp">185-86</biblScope>
                </bibl>
            </sourceDesc>
        </fileDesc>
        <encodingDesc>
            <editorialDecl>
                <hyphenation eol="none">
                    <p>Any dashes occurring in line breaks have been removed.</p>
                </hyphenation>
                <normalization>
                    <p>Obvious and unambiguous compositors&#8217; errors have been silently corrected.</p>
                </normalization>
            </editorialDecl>
            <tagsDecl/>
            <classDecl>
                <taxonomy
                    corresp="http://www.performantsoftware.com/nines_wiki/index.php/Submitting_RDF#.3Cnines:genre.3E"
                    xml:id="g">
                    <bibl>NINES categories for Genre and Material Form at
                        http://www.performantsoftware.com/nines_wiki/index.php/Submitting_RDF#.3Cnines:genre.3E on
                        2009-02-26</bibl>
                    <category xml:id="g1">
                        <catDesc>Bibliography</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g2">
                        <catDesc>Book History</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g3">
                        <catDesc>Collection</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g4">
                        <catDesc>Criticism</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g5">
                        <catDesc>Drama</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g6">
                        <catDesc>Ephemera</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g7">
                        <catDesc>Fiction</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g8">
                        <catDesc>Humor</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g9">
                        <catDesc>Law</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g10">
                        <catDesc>Letters</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g11">
                        <catDesc>Life Writing</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g12">
                        <catDesc>History</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g13">
                        <catDesc>Manuscript</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g14">
                        <catDesc>Nonfiction</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g15">
                        <catDesc>Periodical</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g16">
                        <catDesc>Politics</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g17">
                        <catDesc>Reference Works</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g18">
                        <catDesc>Poetry</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g19">
                        <catDesc>Religion</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g20">
                        <catDesc>Review</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g21">
                        <catDesc>Translation</catDesc>
                    </category>
                    <category xml:id="g22">
                        <catDesc>Travel</catDesc>
                    </category>
                </taxonomy>
            </classDecl>
            <p/>
        </encodingDesc>
        <profileDesc>
            <creation/>
            <langUsage>
                <language ident="EN"/>
            </langUsage>
            <textClass>
                <catRef scheme="#genre" target="#g4"/>
                <catRef scheme="#genre" target="#g14"/>
                <catRef scheme="#genre" target="#g19"/>
                <catRef scheme="#genre" target="#g20"/>
            </textClass>
        </profileDesc>
    </teiHeader>
    <text>
        <body>
            <div xml:id="LitGaz" n="THE LITERARY GAZETTE, AND#JOURNAL OF THE BELLES LETTRES." type="article">
                <docAuthor n="LyByron"/>
                <docDate when="1830-03-20"/>
                <l rend="title">
                    <lb/>
                    <lb/>
                    <seg rend="26px">THE LONDON LITERARY GAZETTE;</seg>
                    <lb/>
                    <seg rend="12px">AND</seg>
                    <lb/>
                    <seg rend="22px">
                        <hi rend="italic">Journal of Belles Lettres, Arts, Sciences &amp;c.</hi>
                    </seg>
                    <lb/>
                    <lb/>
                </l>
                <figure rend="singleLine"/>
                <p rend="hang-indent">
                    <seg rend="10px">This Journal is supplied Weekly, or Monthly, by the principal Booksellers and
                        Newsmen, throughout the Kingdom; but to those who may desire its immediate transmission, by
                        post, we recommend the LITERARY GAZETTE, printed on stamped paper, price One
                        Shilling.</seg>
                </p>
                <figure rend="singleLine"/>
                <table>
                    <row rend="small">
                        <cell rend="left"> No. 687. </cell>
                        <cell rend="center">SATURDAY,&#160;MARCH 20,&#160;1830.</cell>
                        <cell rend="right"> PRICE 8<hi rend="italic">d.</hi>
                        </cell>
                    </row>
                </table>
                <figure rend="doubleLine"/>
                <lb/>
                <l rend="center">
                    <seg rend="18px">REVIEW OF NEW BOOKS.</seg>
                </l>
                <lb/>
                <l rend="center">
                    <seg rend="14px">LADY BYRON&#8217;S LETTER TO MR. MOORE.</seg>
                </l>
                <lb/>
                <p xml:id="JG-x" rend="not-indent">
                    <hi rend="italic">Remarks occasioned by</hi>&#32;<persName key="ThMoore1852"><hi rend="italic"
                            >Mr. Moore&#8217;s</hi></persName>&#32;<name type="title" key="ThMoore1852.Byron"><hi
                            rend="italic">Notices of Lord Byron&#8217;s Life</hi></name>. </p>
                <lb/>
                <p xml:id="LB-1" rend="not-indent">
                    <hi rend="small-caps">There</hi> is no portion of the life of <persName key="LdByron">Lord
                        Byron</persName> which has more excited public curiosity and discussion than the painful
                    event of his separation from his lady, followed as it was by the relinquishment of his native
                    country. Without intruding on the privacies of life, it is therefore with some degree of
                    satisfaction that we find ourselves in a situation to lay some explanation of this matter
                    before our readers, by reprinting the following letter, which <persName key="LyByron">Lady
                        Byron</persName> has addressed to <persName key="ThMoore1852">Mr. Moore</persName>, as a
                    commentary upon certain passages in the first volume of his Memoirs, recently published. It is
                    a moderate but meaning document, and must give rise to much cogitation:— </p>

                <p xml:id="LB-2"> &#8220;I have disregarded various publications in which facts within my own
                    knowledge have been grossly misrepresented; but I am called upon to notice some of the
                    erroneous statements proceeding from one who claims to be considered as <persName key="LdByron"
                        >Lord Byron&#8217;s</persName> confidential and authorised friend. Domestic details ought
                    not to be intruded on the public attention: if, however, they are so intruded, the persons
                    affected by them have a right to refute injurious charges. <persName key="ThMoore1852">Mr.
                        Moore</persName> has promulgated his own impressions of private events in which I was most
                    nearly concerned, as if he possessed a competent knowledge of the subject. Having survived
                        <persName>Lord Byron</persName>, I feel increased reluctance to advert to any circumstances
                    connected with the period of my marriage; nor is it now my intention to disclose them, further
                    than may be indispensably requisite for the end I have in view. Self-vindication is not the
                    motive which actuates me to make this appeal, and the spirit of accusation is unmingled with
                    it; but when the conduct of my parents is brought forward in a disgraceful light, by the
                    passages selected from <persName>Lord Byron&#8217;s</persName> letters, and by the remarks of
                    his biographer, I feel bound to justify their characters from imputations which I know to be
                    false. The passages from <persName>Lord Byron&#8217;s</persName> letters, to which I refer, are
                    the aspersion on my mother&#8217;s character, p. 648, l. 4:—&#8216;<q>My child is very well,
                        and nourishing, I hear; but I must see also. I feel no disposition to resign it to the <hi
                            rend="italic">contagion of its <persName key="JuMilba1822"
                                >grandmother&#8217;s</persName> society</hi>.</q>&#8217; The assertion of her
                    dishonourable conduct in employing a spy, p. 645, l. 7, &amp;c. &#8216;<q>A <persName
                            key="MaClerm1850">Mrs. C.</persName> (now a kind of housekeeper and <hi rend="italic"
                            >spy of <persName>Lady N.&#8217;s</persName></hi>), who, in her better days, was a
                        washerwoman, is supposed to be—by the learned —— very much the occult cause of our domestic
                        discrepancies.</q>&#8217; The seeming exculpation of myself, in the extract, p. 646, with
                    the words immediately following it,—&#8216;<q>Her nearest relatives are a ——;</q>&#8217; where
                    the blank clearly implies something too offensive for publication. These passages tend to throw
                    suspicion on my parents, and give reason to ascribe the separa<cb/>tion either to their direct
                    agency, or to that of &#8216;<q>officious spies</q>&#8217; employed by them.* From the
                    following part of the narrative, p. 642, it must also be inferred that an undue influence was
                    exercised by them for the accomplishment of this purpose. &#8216;<q>It was in a few weeks after
                        the latter communication between us (<persName>Lord Byron</persName> and <persName>Mr.
                            Moore</persName>), that <persName key="LyByron">Lady Byron</persName> adopted the
                        determination of parting from him. She had left London at the latter end of January, on a
                        visit to her <persName key="RaMilba1825">father&#8217;s</persName> house, in
                        Leicestershire, and <persName>Lord Byron</persName> was in a short time to follow her. They
                        had parted in the utmost kindness,—she wrote him a letter full of playfulness and
                        affection, on the road: and immediately on her arrival at Kirkby Mallory, her father wrote
                        to acquaint <persName>Lord Byron</persName> that she would return to him no
                    more.</q>&#8217; In my observations upon this statement, I shall, as far as possible, avoid
                    touching on any matters relating personally to <persName>Lord Byron</persName> and myself. The
                    facts are:—I left London for Kirkby Mallory, the residence of my father and mother, on the 15th
                    of January, 1816. <persName>Lord Byron</persName> had signified to me in writing (Jan. 6th) his
                    absolute desire that I should leave London on the earliest day that I could conveniently fix.
                    It was not safe for me to undertake the fatigue of a journey sooner than the 15th. Previously
                    to my departure, it had been strongly impressed on my mind, that <persName>Lord
                        Byron</persName> was under the influence of insanity. This opinion was derived in a great
                    measure from the communications made to me by his nearest relatives and personal attendant, who
                    had more opportunities than myself of observing him during the latter part of my stay in town.
                    It was even represented to me that he was in danger of destroying himself. <hi rend="italic"
                        >With the concurrence of his family</hi> I had consulted <persName key="MaBaill1823">Dr.
                        Baillie</persName> as a friend (Jan. 8th) respecting this supposed malady. On acquainting
                    him with the state of the case, and with <persName>Lord Byron&#8217;s</persName> desire that I
                    should leave London, <persName>Dr. Baillie</persName> thought that my absence might be
                    advisable as an experiment, assuming the fact of mental derangement; for <persName>Dr.
                        Baillie</persName>, not having had access to <persName>Lord Byron</persName>, could not
                    pronounce a positive opinion on that point. He enjoined that in correspondence with
                        <persName>Lord Byron</persName> I should avoid all but light and soothing topics. Under
                    these impressions, I left London, determined to follow the advice given by <persName>Dr.
                        Baillie</persName>. Whatever might have been the nature of <persName>Lord
                        Byron&#8217;s</persName> conduct towards me from the time of my marriage, yet, supposing
                    him to be in a state of mental alienation, it was not for me, nor for any person of common
                    humanity, to manifest, at that moment, a sense of injury. On the day of my departure, and again
                    on my arrival at Kirkby, Jan. 16th, I wrote to <persName>Lord Byron</persName> in a kind and
                    cheerful tone, according to those medical directions. The last letter was circulated, and
                    employed as a pretext for the charge of my having been subsequently influenced to
                    &#8216;desert&#8217;&#8224; my hus<cb/>band. It has been argued, that I parted from
                        <persName>Lord Byron</persName> in perfect harmony; that feelings, incompatible with any
                    deep sense of injury had dictated the letter which I addressed to him; and that my sentiments
                    must have been changed by persuasion and interference, when I was under the roof of my parents.
                    These assertions and inferences are wholly destitute of foundation. When I arrived at Kirkby
                    Mallory, my parents were unacquainted with the existence of any causes likely to destroy my
                    prospects of happiness; and when I communicated to them the opinion which had been formed
                    concerning <persName>Lord Byron&#8217;s</persName> state of mind, they were most anxious to
                    promote his restoration by every means in their power. They assured those relations who were
                    with him in London, that &#8216;<q>they would devote their whole care and attention to the
                        alleviation of his malady,</q>&#8217; and hoped to make the best arrangements for his
                    comfort, if he could be induced to visit them. With these intentions my mother wrote on the
                    17th to <persName>Lord Byron</persName>, inviting him to Kirkby Mallory. She had always treated
                    him with an affectionate consideration and indulgence, which extended to every little
                    peculiarity of his feelings. Never did an irritating word escape her lips in her whole
                    intercourse with him. The accounts given me after I left <persName>Lord Byron</persName> by the
                    persons in constant intercourse with him, added to those doubts which had before transiently
                    occurred to my mind, as to the reality of the alleged disease; and the reports of his medical
                    attendant were far from establishing the existence of any thing like lunacy. Under this
                    uncertainty, I deemed it right to communicate to my parents, that if I were to consider
                        <persName>Lord Byron&#8217;s</persName> past conduct as that of a person of sound mind,
                    nothing could induce me to return to him. It therefore appeared expedient both to them and
                    myself to consult the ablest advisers. For that object, and also to obtain still further
                    information respecting the appearances which seemed to indicate mental derangement, my mother
                    determined to go to London. She was empowered by me to take legal opinions on a written
                    statement of mine, though I had then reasons for reserving a part of the case from the
                    knowledge even of my father and mother. Being convinced by the result of these inquiries, and
                    by the tenor of <persName>Lord Byron&#8217;s</persName> proceedings, that the notion of
                    insanity was an illusion, I no longer hesitated to authorise such measures as were necessary,
                    in order to secure me from being ever again placed in his power. Conformably with this
                    resolution, my father wrote to him on the 2d of February, to propose an amicable separation.
                        <persName>Lord Byron</persName> at first rejected this proposal; but when it was distinctly
                    notified to him, that if he persisted in his refusal, recourse must be had to legal measures,
                    he agreed to sign a deed of separation. Upon applying to <persName key="StLushi1873">Dr.
                        Lushington</persName>, who was intimately acquainted with all the circumstances, to state
                    in writing what he recollected upon this subject, I received from him the following letter, by
                    which it will be manifest that my mother cannot have been <note place="foot">
                        <figure rend="singleLine"/>
                        <p> * &#8220;<q>The officious spies of his privacy,</q>&#8221; p. 650. </p>
                        <p> &#8224; &#8220;The deserted husband,&#8221; p. 601. </p>
                    </note>
                    <pb xml:id="LB.186"/> actuated by any hostile or ungenerous motives towards <persName>Lord
                        Byron</persName>. </p>

                <floatingText>
                    <body>
                        <docAuthor n="StLushi1873"/>
                        <docDate when="1830-01-31"/>
                        <listPerson type="recipient">
                            <person>
                                <persName n="Byron, Lady" key="LyByron"/>
                            </person>
                        </listPerson>
                        <div xml:id="LB.1" n="Stephen Lushington to Lady Byron, 31 January 1830" type="letter">
                            <p xml:id="LB-3"> &#8220;&#8216;My dear <persName key="LyByron">Lady
                                Byron</persName>,—I can rely upon the accuracy of my memory for the following
                                statement. I was originally consulted by <persName key="JuMilba1822">Lady
                                    Noel</persName> on your behalf, whilst you were in the country; the
                                circumstances detailed by her were such as justified a separation, but they were
                                not of that aggravated description as to render such a measure indispensable. On
                                    <persName>Lady Noel&#8217;s</persName> representation, I deemed a
                                reconciliation with <persName key="LdByron">Lord Byron</persName> practicable, and
                                felt most sincerely a wish to aid in effecting it. There was not on <persName>Lady
                                    Noel&#8217;s</persName> part any exaggeration of the facts; nor, so far as I
                                could perceive, any determination to prevent a return to <persName>Lord
                                    Byron</persName>: certainly none was expressed when I spoke of a
                                reconciliation. When you came to town in about a fortnight, or perhaps more, after
                                my first interview with <persName>Lady Noel</persName>, I was for the first time
                                informed by you of facts utterly unknown, as I have no doubt, to <persName
                                    key="RaMilba1825">Sir Ralph</persName> and <persName>Lady Noel</persName>. On
                                receiving this additional information, my opinion was entirely changed: I
                                considered a reconciliation impossible. I declared my opinion, and added, that if
                                such an idea should be entertained, I could not, either professionally or
                                otherwise, take any part towards effecting it. Believe me, very faithfully yours, </p>
                            <closer>
                                <signed> &#8216;<persName><hi rend="small-caps">Steph. Lushington.</hi></persName>
                                </signed>
                                <dateline> &#8216;<hi rend="italic">Great George Street, Jan.</hi> 31, 1830.&#8217;
                                </dateline>
                            </closer>

                        </div>
                    </body>
                </floatingText>

                <p xml:id="LB-4"> &#8220;I have only to observe, that if the statements on which my legal advisers
                    (the late <persName key="SaRomil1818">Sir Samuel Romilly</persName> and <persName
                        key="StLushi1873">Dr. Lushington</persName>) formed their opinions, were false, the
                    responsibility and the odium should rest with me only. I trust that the facts which I have here
                    briefly recapitulated will absolve my father and mother from all accusations with regard to the
                    part they took in the separation between <persName>Lord Byron</persName> and myself. They
                    neither originated, instigated, nor advised, that separation; and they cannot be condemned for
                    having afforded to their daughter the assistance and protection which she claimed. There is no
                    other near relative to vindicate their memory from insult. I am therefore compelled to break
                    the silence which I had hoped always to observe, and to solicit from the readers of
                        <persName>Lord Byron&#8217;s</persName> life an impartial consideration of the testimony
                    extorted from me. </p>

                <l rend="right"> &#8220;<persName><hi rend="small-caps">A. I. Noel Byron</hi></persName>. </l>
                <l rend="indent20">
                    <seg rend="14px">&#8220;<hi rend="italic">Hanger Hill, Feb.</hi> 19, 1830.&#8221;</seg>
                </l>

                <p xml:id="LB-5"> We understand that <persName key="ThMoore1852">Mr. Moore</persName> has signified
                    his intention of subjoining these <hi rend="italic">Remarks</hi> of <persName key="LyByron"
                        >Lady Byron</persName> to the new edition of his work. </p>
                <lb/>
                <lb/>
                <lb/>
            </div>
        </body>

    </text>
</TEI>
