Memoirs of the Life of Sir Walter Scott, Bart.
Walter Scott to Lord Byron, 3 July 1812
“Edinburgh, July 3d, 1812.
“My Lord,
“I am uncertain if I ought to profit by the apology
which is afforded me, by a very obliging communication from our acquaintance,
John Murray of Fleet Street, to give
your Lordship the present trouble. But my intrusion concerns a large debt of
gratitude due to your Lordship, and a much less important, one of explanation,
which I think I owe to myself, as I dislike standing low in the opinion of any
person whose talents rank so highly in my own, as your Lordship’s most
deservedly do.
“The first count, as our
technical language expresses it, relates to the high pleasure I have received
from the Pilgrimage of Childe
Harold, and from its precursors; the former, with all its classical
associations, some of which are lost on so poor a scholar as I am, possesses
the additional charm of vivid and animated description, mingled with original
sentiment;—
| LETTER TO LORD BYRON—JULY, 1812. | 399 |
but besides this
debt, which I owe your Lordship in common with the rest of the reading public,
I have to acknowledge my particular thanks for your having distinguished by
praise, in the work which your Lordship rather dedicated in general to satire,
some of my own literary attempts. And this leads me to put your Lordship right
in the circumstances respecting the sale of Marmion, which had reached you in a distorted
and misrepresented form, and which, perhaps, I have some reason to complain,
were given to the public without more particular enquiry. The poem, my Lord,
was not written upon contract for a sum of money—though it is too true that it
was sold and published in a very unfinished state, which I have since
regretted, to enable me to extricate myself from some engagements which fell
suddenly upon me, by the unexpected misfortunes of a very near relation. So
that, to quote statute and precedent, I really come under the case cited by
Juvenal, though not quite in the
extremity of the classic author— Esurit, intactam Paridi nisi vendit Agaven. |
And so much for a mistake, into which your Lordship might easily fall,
especially as I generally find it the easiest way of stopping sentimental
compliments on the beauty, &c., of certain poetry, and the delights which
the author must have taken in the composition, by assigning the readiest reason
that will cut the discourse short, upon a subject where one must appear either
conceited, or affectedly rude and cynical.
“As for my attachment to literature, I sacrificed
for the pleasure of pursuing it very fair chances of opulence and professional
honours, at a time of life when I fully knew their value, and I am not ashamed
to say, that in deriving advantages in compensation from the partial
400 | LIFE OF SIR WALTER SCOTT. | |
favour of the public, I have added some comforts and
elegancies to a bare independence. I am sure your Lordship’s good sense
will easily put this unimportant egotism to the right account,—for though I do
not know the motive would make me enter into controversy with a fair or an unfair literary critic—I may be well excused for a wish
to clear my personal character from any tinge of mercenary or sordid feeling in
the eyes of a contemporary of genius. Your Lordship will likewise permit me to
add, that you would have escaped the trouble of this explanation, had I not
understood that the satire alluded to had been suppressed, not to be reprinted.
For in removing a prejudice on your Lordship’s own mind, I had no
intention of making any appeal by or through you to the public, since my own
habits of life have rendered my defence as to avarice or rapacity rather too
easy.
“Leaving this foolish matter where it lies, I have
to request your Lordship’s acceptance of my best thanks for the
flattering communication which you took the trouble to make Mr Murray on my behalf, and which could not
fail to give me the gratification, which I am sure you intended. I dare say our
worthy bibliopolist overcoloured his report of your Lordship’s
conversation with the Prince Regent, but I
owe my thanks to him nevertheless, for the excuse he has given me for intruding
these pages on your Lordship. Wishing you health, spirit, and perseverance, to
continue your pilgrimage through the interesting countries which you have still
to pass with Childe Harold, I
have the honour to be, my Lord, your Lordship’s obedient servant,
“P.S. Will your Lordship permit me a verbal
criticism on Childe Harold,
were it only to show I have read his Pilgrimage with attention?
‘Nuestra Dama de la Pena’
means, I suspect, not our Lady of Crime or
| CORRESPONDENCE WITH LORD BYRON. | 401 |
Punishment, but our Lady of the
Cliff; the difference is, I believe, merely in the accentuation of
‘peña.’”
Juvenal (110 AD fl.)
Roman satirist noted, in contrast to Horace, for his angry manner.
John Murray II (1778-1843)
The second John Murray began the
Quarterly Review in 1809 and
published works by Scott, Byron, Austen, Crabbe, and other literary notables.