The “Pope” of Holland House
Henry Holland to John Whishaw, 12 August 1812
The Mediterranean, Aug. 12,
1812.
You see, my dear Sir, a very indefinite date for a letter, but
the truth is I can give no other, as no land at present appears in sight from which
to derive a name to the place where I now am writing. I may tell you, however, in
the outset that I am on my passage between Gibraltar and Sicily, that the vessel on
her voyage will stop a day or two at the capital of his
Sardinian Majesty, and that I purpose to leave there for a
conveyance to England. This, among other letters which the leisure of a voyage will
enable me to write. I trust you will not consider this long delay in addressing you
a breach of the promise I made when last I saw you in London. For the three months
just elapsed I have been passing so rapidly from one object to another that though
moments of leisure have now and then come in between, I have always been disposed
to wait till the tide was completely gone by, more especially as the leisure was
not always accompanied with secure means of transmitting the letter I might have
written. There are two sides of some questions in Portugal as well as elsewhere, if
one chooses to say a little on both, it is well to know that a letter gets into no
other hands than those to which it is addressed. Having thus shortly explained to
you my reasons for delay, I will mention a few of the circumstances which struck my
attention while travelling through Portugal, such only, however, as I conceive may
interest you from the connection with the great
289 |
|
1812 |
contest we are at present carrying on in the Peninsula. My object, you probably
know, in throwing myself so near a scene of warfare, was to see the practice of the
military hospitals, from which I conceived that a great deal of practical advantage
might be derived, and so in fact I have found it. Of these great establishments, I
do not speak to you further than to say that they are in the highest degree
creditable to the military system of the country. I have seen hospitals in England,
Scotland, and Ireland, but none superior, or even equal, in their arrangement and
interior economy, to some of those which I visited in Portugal; and I would
particularly mention those at Santarem and Alicantes, as complete models of what
such establishments ought to be, whether military or otherwise.
Of Portugal and the Portuguese at large what shall I say to you?
Nature has created a fine country, and a soil teeming with riches; the progressive
changes of national form and character have covered it with people, whom their own
sufficiency and the courtesy of other nations have called civilised, but who are in truth still living in the Middle Ages, who want
the energy to become great, and who, in their modes of society, their literature,
and their arts, are unquestionably among the lowest in the scale of the communities
of Europe. If I were called upon for an epithet, I should say that the Portuguese
was a paltry character; his physiognomy is poor, with little expression but that of
an ignorant self-sufficiency; his dress carries the same features with it, a
slovenly tawdriness, without propriety or
290 |
|
From Dr. Holland |
meaning; his conversation is insipid and ill-informed; he crouches equally under
the oppression of civil and ecclesiastical tyranny; he is indolent in his habits
both of body and of mind. I am aware of the caution that is necessary in speaking
of national character, and especially when it is a stranger who speaks. I would
request you, therefore, to consider the opinion just given as a very general one,
and to make all the deductions from it that you think proper.
If Portugal survives the present contest she will come out of the
furnace with many of her impurities done away. The monks are every day declining in
number, wealth, and reputation, freedom of thought and speech are gradually
extending, the aristocracy of birth is in some way giving way to that of merit, and
the restoration of the military character to the nation may introduce some of those
sterner virtues which nevertheless separated from their origin are virtues among a people.
Of the war in the Peninsula and its prospects I am at a loss how
to speak to you, and it is not impossible that your judgments at home may on the
whole be more accurate than the often partial ones which are formed on the spot.
Even at this time you may have heard of the victory of Lord W. near Salamanca, and before you receive my letter will be
acquainted with all the more immediate consequences of this event. They cannot fail
to be very important at a time when the distant occupation of the French armies
prevents any considerable reinforcement being given to those in Spain. From all the
information I have been able to collect in Portugal, and more lately
291 |
|
1812 |
in Gibraltar, I am induced to believe that before
Marmont’s defeat, the actual
number of the French in Spain was about 120,000 men, of whom 30,000 continue with
Soult in Andalusia. Reduced now to
100,000 men, supposing this statement to be correct, there is every reason to
believe that they are insufficient to maintain their ground over the extent of the
Peninsula. Diminution of numbers, in fact, is a threefold evil to them; since,
beyond the immediate injury, it has the effect of facilitating the desertion of
foreigners from their army, and of increasing the amount and activity of the
guerilla force, which is composed of Germans, Poles, Swiss, and Italians, as well
as of Spaniards and which has comparatively little efficiency against a numerous
army broken, dispirited, and declining in numbers. Speaking of discretion, I can
mention to you a fact on the best authority, that between the entrance of the
French into Andalusia and the present time, upwards of 12,000 men from the armies,
chiefly Germans, have fled into the garrison of Gibraltar. The perseverance of
Soult in the south of Spain is wonderfully great, arising,
it is said, from the positive orders of Napoleon, on no account to relinquish the siege of Cadiz. Every one
admires his talents in meeting the numerous difficulties opposed to him, the
necessity of maintaining the siege, the army of General
Hill, the troops of Balisteros1 and the difficulty of
provisioning his soldiers, this situation would now appear to be critical in the
extreme; and I doubt not that before you receive this letter you will have heard of
his 1 Commander of the Spanish forces. |
292 |
|
From Dr. Holland |
having withdrawn before Cadiz, a
mortifying circumstance to the French, who have constructed works there on a vast
scale, and have just attained the means of throwing their shells from distances of
four miles into the very heart of the city. Even when at the mouth of the Guadiana,
I listened with a sort of awe to the dull, heavy sound of their distant artillery,
and near to the bay of Cadiz the report of their morning and evening bombardment
became tremendous.
You will conjecture from what I say that I have hopes of the
eventual success of the cause in the Peninsula. I certainly have so, and yet I can
hardly persuade myself that the Spaniards deserve or that they will adequately
avail themselves of the liberty which they seem not unlikely to obtain. I have not
myself seen much of them, but every account I have obtained bears testimony to the
general indifference they show as to the issues of the war, and speaks also of the
strong dislike they frequently manifest to their English allies. I hope that recent
events may make some change in this feeling, but it has certainly hitherto existed
to a great extent. The Spanish regular armies are slowly recruited, badly
officered, and deficient, it would seem, with the spirit and discipline of war. At
Alicantes, in the centre of Portugal, I saw a brigade of their artillery which had
come there without order, and for no other evident purpose than that of plundering
the English commissariat stock. Balisteros
is unquestionably one of the most active and independent of their generals. He has
at present 12,000 troops with him in the
293 |
|
1812 |
neighbourhood of Gibraltar, but judging from those I saw, they must be in a
wretched state of equipment. The guerilla bands bear only a partial testimony in
favour of the native exertion of the Spaniards. They are, as I have remarked
before, variously composed, and not a small part of them by deserters from the
French service rendered desperate by their circumstances. The importance of the
guerilla warfare, however, cannot be too highly noted, and if Spain should finally
obtain good generals, and men of enlarged public talents, they will probably be
drawn from this source.
As regards our own part in this extraordinary war, if I were
asked what circumstance I have thought of greatest importance in it, I should say,
the amount of the property tax, and the life
of Lord
Wellington. Even knowing the total supernumerary expense of the
Peninsular War to England, one cannot help being astonished and confounded by the
magnitude of the items, as they strike the attention in passing through the
country. The commissariat department, for instance, which carries provisions 2, 3,
or even 400 miles, for an immense moving population of more than 50,000 people
exclusive of the horses in our cavalry, and all the innumerable beasts of burden
attached to the army. Nearly 1,000 boats, 10,000 mules, besides oxen and asses, are
perpetually employed in that great service of transport. I do not exaggerate the
fact in saying that the expenses of the muleteer establishment alone fall little
short of £1,000,000 a year. If Mr.
Vansittart1 can keep this
1 Chancellor of the Exchequer. |
294 |
|
From Dr. Holland |
up, well and good; I hope he can, for it
is indispensable to the existence and activity of our armies in this country.
Mr. Perceval, in as far as we can
understand the ground of dispute between him and the Marquess of Wellesley, seemed to have had his doubts on the
subject. Then with respect to Lord Wellington, the best
testimony to the superiority of his talent is the general impression that were
anything untoward to befall him, all must be given up. He undoubtedly is one of the
most extraordinary men we have had in these our later days of history, and with
certain characteristics which admirably well fit him for his present exalted but
difficult situation. One remarkable quality which distinguishes him is the
singleness of his decisions, and the steady resolution with which he carries his
decisions into effect. Not even his generals know until the moment of action what
is to be done, A division or a regiment march a hundred miles, without being aware
how other divisions or regiments are employed; they are astonished when, at a
certain spot and time, the whole army is instantaneously assembled from different
places and lines of march. Some generals, it is said, are offended by this
perpetual reserve in their leader, but the confidence of the army at large is kept
up, and every attempt at espionage rendered fruitless. This you will recognise as
the feature of a great mind. Another striking fact in Lord
Wellington’s military character (and on that I have myself had
several opportunities of knowing) is his singularly minute attention to every
department in the army. He knows more of his commissariat, of his army hospitals,
of his waggon train, &c, than any 295 |
|
1812 |
person even
immediately connected with these several departments, and there is no transaction
relating to any one of them which does not pass more or less directly through his
hands. This gives a unity and a fitting in of parts which were before very little
known to the British army. With these great qualities as a general, Lord
Wellington is said to have the further one of a remarkably even
temper, or at least to have a facility in assuming that tone of countenance and
manner which suits with the occasions of the time. In short, whatever Mr. Cobbett may say, there are features about the
man’s character which entitle him to command, and that on a great scale. I
fancy, from what I heard his friend Mr.
Sydenham say (who is lately come to Portugal from Cadiz), that it is
likely the Spanish Government will now entrust him with some administrative powers
of a more enlarged kind.
With respect to our army as distinct from its general, it is a
brave army, and a well-disciplined army, superior to the French in equipment, and
in many points of military conduct. But I believe we pride ourselves too much in
England on the idea that our soldiers are superior to the French in generosity of
feeling, in refraining from plunder, and from the various outrages common to
military campaigns. I would willingly believe, and I do believe, that our officers
would not have permitted under any circumstances the dreadful work of barbarity and
destruction which was not only permitted but incited and encouraged by the
principal French officers during Massena’s retreat. But I imagine that the common soldier is
much the same in all countries and ages of the world,
296 |
|
From Dr. Holland |
The work of war has everywhere one object, and the lower
agents in it, whatever their original national habits and feelings are in the
progress of time, pretty much identified in character. That English soldiers in
Portugal will plunder if they can, and that even young English officers can behave
in the most uncourteous and brutal manner to the population of the country, I am
reluctantly compelled to admit by the instances I have myself seen; but at the same
time I will state it as most highly to the honour of Lord
Wellington, and the principal officers of the army that they assist
themselves in every possible way to moderate and abridge these almost necessary
evils. Lord Wellington’s efforts of this kind have been
great beyond measure, risking in some degree even his popularity with the army. He
has deserved and obtained the gratitude of the Portuguese nation, who, I believe,
are all sensible to his endeavours on their behalf.
I wish that those among our countrymen who think little of the
importance of Ireland were present for a short time with our army in the Peninsula.
At the time I first came to the military hospitals in Portugal, they were filled
with the wounded from Badajos, and I think I do not exaggerate the matter in saying
that half the whole number were Irishmen. It is, indeed, probable that the
proportion in the army at large may be somewhat less considerable, but even this is
a demonstration what are the troops resorted to on the most trying and desperate
occasions.
I had intended to say something to you about the state of the
country in Portugal, but I have not left
297 |
|
1812 |
myself room
to do this. In a few words I may say that it is everywhere marked by the ravages of
war. I have been at Santander, which for some months was the headquarters of
Massena. It is a ruined city, I have followed the track of his army in various
directions; the track is marked by deserted villages, by roofless houses, by the
misery of the remaining inhabitants. I have seen the sepulchres of the Portuguese
kings torn open by their hands and the bones scattered abroad. The deplorable
poverty and wretchedness of the people on the frontiers is equally great. This
district has so long been the scene of contest, of alternate advance and retreat,
that everything in it is ruin and desolation. The difficulties of travelling
through the country are very great, and I have now and then been subjected to
grievances as great as any I recall to have experienced in Iceland.
An interval of a few days has expired in the midst of this
letter which gives me the means of telling you that we are near Alicante, in
Valencia. The day before yesterday I landed at a small village in Murcia, and
amused myself by dancing fandango with the peasants, a noble race of people, open
and generous in feature, strong in limb and nerve, who merit all the amount of
contrast which Lord Byron draws between them and
the Portuguese.
With respect to my future plans I can tell you little more than
that I think of spending two months in rambling through Sicily. I once thought of
Greece, but I believe I must give that up—non
cuivis homini contingit adire corinthum. It is not
improbable that this letter may reach London when
298 |
|
From Dr.Holland |
you are absent from it, but for want of another I must
necessarily use the direction to Lincoln’s Inn.
How much of extraordinary event has occurred among you since I
left England, and how much is still on the tapis! I do hope
all may end well but they are strange times in which we live.
Adieu, my dear Sir,
Ever believe me most truly yours,
Francisco Ballesteros (1770-1832)
Spanish commander who fought against the French in the Peninsular War bu who refused to
accept Wellington's leadership; he was defeated in the subsequent Spanish civil war and
spent his later years in France.
Sir Henry Holland, first baronet (1788-1873)
English physician and frequenter of Holland House, the author of
Travels in the Ionian Isles, Albania, Thessaly, Macedonia etc. during 1812 and
1813 (1814) and
Recollections of Past Life (1872). His
second wife, Saba, was the daughter of Sydney Smith.
André Massena (1758-1817)
Napoleon's field marshall who was defeated by Wellington in the Peninsular
Campaign.
Emperor Napoleon I (1769-1821)
Military leader, First Consul (1799), and Emperor of the French (1804), after his
abdication he was exiled to Elba (1814); after his defeat at Waterloo he was exiled to St.
Helena (1815).
Spencer Perceval (1762-1812)
English statesman; chancellor of the exchequer (1807), succeeded the Duke of Portland as
prime minister (1809); he was assassinated in the House of Commons.
Nicholas Soult (1769-1851)
Marshal of France and commander in the Peninsular War.
Thomas Sydenham (1780-1816)
Educated at Harrow and Christ Church, Oxford, he was a diplomat in India and Persia
before serving under Wellington during the Peninsular War.
Nicholas Vansittart, first Baron Bexley (1766-1851)
Educated at Christ Church, Oxford, he was a Pittite MP for Hastings (1796-1802), Old
Sarum (1802-12), East Grinstead (1812), and Harwich (1812-23); he was Chancellor of the
exchequer (1812-23).
Richard Wellesley, first marquess Wellesley (1760-1842)
The son of Garret Wesley (1735-1781) and elder brother of the Duke of Wellington; he was
Whig MP, Governor-general of Bengal (1797-1805), Foreign Secretary (1809-12), and
Lord-lieutenant of Ireland (1821-28); he was created Marquess Wellesley in 1799.