The “Pope” of Holland House
        John Whishaw to Thomas Smith, 21 October 1820
        
        
          
        
        
          
        
       
      
      
      
      
     
     
    
    Oct. 21, 1820. 
    
     In your last letter you expressed a wish to know something of
                                what I saw in Scotland. After leaving Mr.
                                    Kennedy’s I travelled by the Ayrshire coast, and the shores of
                                the Forth of Clyde to Greenock and Glasgow. Greenock, the port of Glasgow, is a
                                beautiful town which has risen up during the last thirty years, and considering the
                                picturesque country in which it is situated, is one of the most striking seaports
                                in the island. The docks and Custom House are magnificent, and everything appeared
                                to be flourishing. It has no less than twenty-eight steamboats, which go regularly
                                to Glasgow, Inverary and many of the lochs, to several of the different islands,
                                and to Belfast and Liverpool. This new power will change the face of Nature in many
                                parts of the High-
| 222 | 
![]() ![]()  | 
| Dugald Stewart | 
lands. Places at the
                                distance (by land) of perhaps a hundred miles, and hardly accessible before, are
                                now become the residences of Glasgow merchants, who visit them every week or
                                fortnight during the summer. 
    
     From Glasgow I went to Mr. Dugald
                                    Stewart, who resides at Kinneil, near Linlithgow, a curious old
                                house strikingly situated near the Firth of Forth. It belongs to the Duke of Hamilton, and is one of the most ancient
                                possessions of the family. I passed two days very agreeably and instructively with
                                Mr. and Mrs. Stewart and their daughter. He
                                had just finished the second part of his introduction to the Encyclopedia, and was in excellent health and spirits,
                                and, indeed, in high “Whiggism.” He was very kind, frank, and
                                communicative; and as he has lived in intimacy with some of the most considerable
                                Scotch literati of the last age—Dr. Robertson, Adam
                                    Smith, and Ferguson—you
                                may suppose that my time was passed very pleasantly. 
    
     From thence I went to Edinburgh, where I could stay only three
                                days, during which I went over into Fife, to Mr.
                                    Ferguson, of Raith, a delightful and most hospitable house. Whilst I
                                was there I heard the famous preacher Dr.
                                    Chalmers, who happened to be at the neighbouring town of Kirkcaldy,
                                the birthplace of Adam Smith, and his
                                residence when he wrote the “Wealth of Nations.” 
    
    Dr. Chalmers did not satisfy my
                                expectations. He has considerable powers, but is exaggerated in manner and matter.
                                He preaches the high Calvinistic doctrines, and is, of course, deficient in good
                                sense, 
| 223 | 
![]() ![]()  | 
| Lord Liverpool | 
 and probably also in good faith. I
                                greatly doubt his sincerity. But he is an excellent parish priest at Glasgow, very
                                active and judicious in all matters relating to the poor, and he probably considers
                                these violent doctrines as being most popular and efficient. 
    
     I returned from Edinburgh by the great North road, making a
                                slight détour by Melrose and Kelso, along the banks of the
                                Tweed, where I saw Abbotsford, Walter
                                    Scott’s place, which has nothing remarkable in a beautiful
                                country. 
    
     The Queen’s trial is
                                going on very heavily; but it is not certain yet whether it will be carried against
                                her in the House of Lords. Lord Byron has sent
                                    Murray a tragedy reported to be very
                                fine, called “Marino Falieri, Doge of
                                    Venice.” 
    
    
    Queen Caroline of Brunswick-Wolfenbüttel  (1768-1821)  
                  Married the Prince of Wales in 1795 and separated in 1796; her husband instituted
                        unsuccessful divorce proceedings in 1820 when she refused to surrender her rights as
                        queen.
               
 
    Thomas Chalmers  (1780-1847)  
                  Scottish divine and leader of the Free Church of Scotland; he was professor of moral
                        philosophy at St. Andrews (1823-28) and professor of divinity at Edinburgh
                        (1828-43).
               
 
    Adam Ferguson  (1723-1816)  
                  Professor of philosophy at Edinburgh University; author of 
An Essay on
                            the History of Civil Society (1767) and other historical and philosophical
                        works.
               
 
    Robert Ferguson of Raith  (1768-1840)  
                  Scottish advocate, MP, and mineral collector; there is a notable portrait by Henry
                        Raeburn, “The Archers.” In 1807 he was convicted of criminal conversation with Lady
                        Elgin.
               
 
    
    
    Thomas Francis Kennedy  (1788-1879)  
                  Educated at Harrow (where he was a contemporary of Byron) and Edinburgh University, he
                        was a Whig MP for Ayr (1818-34) who married the daughter of Sir Samuel Romilly and was a
                        friend of Francis Jeffrey.
               
 
    John Murray II  (1778-1843)  
                  The second John Murray began the 
Quarterly Review in 1809 and
                        published works by Scott, Byron, Austen, Crabbe, and other literary notables.
               
 
    William Robertson  (1721-1793)  
                  Educated at Edinburgh University of which he became principal (1762), he was a
                        highly-regarded historian, the author of 
History of Scotland in the Reign
                            of Queen Mary and of King James VI (1759) and 
The History of the
                            Reign of Charles V (1769).
               
 
    
    Adam Smith  (1723-1790)  
                  Friend of David Hume and professor of logic at Glasgow University (1751); he wrote 
Theory of the Moral Sentiments (1759) and 
The
                            Wealth of Nations (1776).
               
 
    Dugald Stewart  (1753-1828)  
                  Professor of moral philosophy at Edinburgh University (1785-1809); he was author of 
Elements of the Philosophy of the Human Mind (1792-93).
               
 
    Helen D'Arcy Stewart  [née Cranstoun]   (1765-1838)  
                  The daughter of George Cranstoun (d. 1788); she was a Scottish poet and, after becoming
                        the second wife of Dugald Stewart in 1790, a noted Edinburgh hostess.
               
 
    
                  Encyclopædia Britannica; or, a Dictionary of Arts and Sciences, compiled upon
                        a new plan.   3 vols   (Edinburgh: Colin Macfarquhar, 1771).   3 vols, 1768-1771, ed. William Smellie; 10 vols, 1777–1784, ed. James Tytler; 18 vols,
                        1788–1797, ed. Colin Macfarquhar and George Gleig; supplement to 3rd, 2 vols, 1801; 20
                        vols, 1801–1809, ed. James Millar; 20 vols, 1817, ed. James Millar; supplement to 5th, 6
                        vols, 1816–1824, ed. Macvey Napier; 20 vols, 1820–1823, ed. Charles Maclaren; 21 vols,
                        1830–1842, ed. Macvey Napier and James Browne.