205 |
In 1844 Mr. Harness, under the name of “Presbyter Catholicus,” wrote a pamphlet which attracted considerable attention. It was called forth by a proposal on the part of the Bishop of London to establish a “Metropolitan Visiting and Relief Association.” Mr. Harness was strongly opposed to such a measure. He considered that charitable relief could be more advantageously bestowed in private, to those with whose wants and characters we are personally acquainted, than by the means of the agency of any public society. “The private course,” he remarks, “is safest for ourselves, without desiring to derogate from the praise of those who extend themselves beyond the bounds of their ordinary duties to set on foot schemes of distant charity, and who are led by an ardent zeal for the welfare of their race to divert the streams of their benevolence into channels far wider and more
206 | PUBLIC CHARITIES. |
“Public charities,” he observes, “create the necessity they relieve, but do not relieve all the necessity they create;” and he strongly objects to money being distributed in that way, except under the careful supervision of a responsible and well qualified Government officer. This opinion he corroborates by facts, in the following terms:
“Pray, my Lord, allow me to call your attention for a moment to the consequences which, from the natural course of things, might have been expected, and which in fact have, to a certain degree, followed the institution of this society.
“In the midst of the mildest Winter we ever happen to remember, when the poor at the north of London were perhaps better off than they had been for years; during a Christmas which, it is said, witnessed the dressing of more meat dinners in St. Giles’s than its cellars and its garrets had for a long time rejoiced in the savour of; at this moment—when such a measure was perfectly uncalled-
PUBLIC CHARITIES. | 207 |
208 | EFFECTS OF THE |
* “This circumstance is alluded to, but very tenderly, in the last Report of the Mendicity Society: ‘The managers are of opinion, that the great facility now afforded the idle and profligate to obtain food and shelter has greatly diminished their anxiety to seek for employment; and that very many have been drawn to London who would never have ventured to come there, without the security now afforded to them against the evils to which improvidence would formerly have exposed them.’—Report for 1844.” |
RELIEF ASSOCIATION. | 209 |
Mr. Harness proceeds to trace the probable course of the movement in a particular parish:—“Let us look at the working of the scheme. The Rev. Mr. A., Incumbent of B., is anxious to show his respect for his diocesan, by acting in correspondence with your Lordship’s views. He is also not unwilling to possess himself of a portion of the funds, which he finds are at the disposal of the General Committee, and
210 | QUALITIES NECESSARY |
FOR DISTRICT-VISITORS. | 211 |
“Such are the qualities necessary to form a good visitor of the poor—who is to go, a stranger among strangers, to deal with affliction in all its variety of forms, and with imposture in all its Protean transformations. Can the General Committee really suppose that the characters fitted for such an office are readily to be met with? or that, when met with, they will require no discipline and education to prepare them for its duties? Talk of the imaginative powers of the lover, the lunatic, or the poet! Why, such persons are not half so ‘compact of imagination’ as the staid members of this new Joint Stock Charity Association! A very few days since, one of its zealous supporters told your Lordship’s correspondent that ‘nothing was easier to be met with than men and women calculated to act as district visitors, for the only qualities required were sincere religious principles and sound common sense!’ Nothing more! The two rarest qualities in the world to be found—apart; and, of course, still more rare to be met with—in union! But supposing the Parish of B. should be most highly blest, and be peculiarly rich in individuals of this happy
212 | NECESSARY DUTIES. |
“But when these, the most valuable members of his congregation, have drifted off from him, where is the Rev. Mr. A. to look for his coadjutors? He may command the services of the morbid pietist—of the restless fanatic—of the idler who is weary of himself—and of the prying, curious, chattering busy-body who wants to know how everybody lives
UNSUITABLE VISITORS. | 213 |
214 | UNSUITABLE VISITORS. |
“This is the class of persons, my Lord, on whom will devolve the most delicate charge that can be entrusted to the despatch of man—the charge of administering comfort to the desponding, the suffering, and the broken-hearted. At first, for a month or so, the Rev. Mr. A. may persuade a few more able hands to assist him in getting his scheme out of dock and setting it afloat. But these will one by one desert him, and eventually leave it to be worked by the sort of people I have described. At all events, from July to November, when every body is out of town, into such hands it must inevitably fall.
“But, however, after a little time, ‘The B. Visiting and Relief Society’ is formed. The President, the Treasurer, the Secretary, the Committee, are appointed; the number of visitors is complete; the grant from the great central fund has been paid, and is increased by a numerous list of annual subscriptions. The parish is divided into districts, and a certain number of ladies and gentlemen appointed as superintendents to each.
INJUDICIOUS CHARITY. | 215 |
“You set up an office for the distribution of unearned food and fuel! Immediately, all the idle and improvident, the drunken and the dissolute, will flock to the scramble; and these will be followed, in rapidly increasing numbers, by others whom the display of the gifts bestowed upon the first applicants will tempt away from their daily labour, to try the chance of winning for themselves a share of those fruits of idleness which are, at first, so sweet in flavour, but which leave so bitter an after-taste.
“I cannot refrain from citing, on this subject, some cases described by Mr. Brushfield.* This gentleman was one of the parish officers of Christ Church, Spitalfields. He states: ‘My general mode of investigation was, not to make inquiries elsewhere, but to visit the residences of those persons whom I suspected—which, by the way, was most of the paupers—first on the Saturday, and next on the Sunday. On Saturday they expected me, and I had, generally, some cause to doubt the appearance of their dwellings on that day. In general, those who wanted to impose upon us over-coloured the picture; and certainly the pictures they drew were often very appalling. One Saturday, accompanied by one of the churchwardens, I visited ten places. The scenes of distress were
* In the same Parliamentary Paper, p. 279. |
216 | SIMULATION OF DISTRESS. |
IMPOSITION. | 217 |
“‘On the Sunday morning’ (continues Mr. Brushfield), ‘I renewed my visits. The first case I went to was that of this man, Anster. It was about nine o’clock in the morning when I called. I opened the door, and then knocked, when I found they were in bed. I saw the wife jump out of bed, and run in great haste to fling a cloth over a table which was standing in the middle of the room; but, in her haste to get away, and in her confusion, she pulled the covering off, and exposed to my view a large piece of beef, a piece of mutton, and parcels of tea, sugar, bread, butter, &c. The man called from the bed, ‘D—n them, never mind them; you know they belong to your father.’ I told them that was enough, and immediately left the place. They never afterwards applied for relief.
“‘When I visited the house of Bagg’ (continues Mr. Brushfield), ‘I found Mrs. Bagg out of bed and at breakfast; she had her tea, and he had his coffee. I saw a neck of mutton on one shelf, and two loaves
218 | DETECTION. |
“But,” resumes Mr. Harness, “I will take the very fairest view of the working of the B. Society, I will imagine the impossible case, that no imposition shall be practised on the visitors—or, at all events, that the plans of the Rev. Mr. A.—— and his Committee have been so well arranged as to crush it in the bud. The parish is split into such small and manageable portions that every visitor has only a very few houses under his superintendence. These he will call at from time to time; and, by personally making himself acquainted with the circumstances and wants of each family, will not only anticipate the necessity of any application for assistance, but preclude the possibility of fraud. Now, admirable as this scheme may appear to many, I beg leave to state, from my intimate knowledge of the best class of the labouring poor, that, though they may not exhibit any incivility to the strange lady or gentleman who thus—impertinently and without invitation—forces her or his way into their apartments, they feel, as they will very often express themselves, quite as much hurt by such an
DETECTION. | 219 |
“The English population will be fallen low, indeed, when the industrious classes are so degraded as to have lost all sense of the reverence which is due to their own hearths, and not to feel the republican part of their national character rise indignantly against the arrogance which considers a better coat and a fuller purse as affording any one who may choose to enter upon the office a sufficient warrant for breaking in, at all times, however inconvenient, upon their families and interfering with their concerns. ‘Poverty has naturally a proud spirit: pauperism a base one—now servile, now insolent.’*
“But I will return to the Rev. Mr. A——, and the B. Visiting Society. It is now ready for business; the season for its operation has commenced. Work is slack; the snow is on the ground; and
220 | DISCRIMINATION REQUISITE |
IN AFFORDING RELIEF. | 221 |
222 | EVIL EFFECTS |
“Will he, then, assist this case? If he does, he will confer on the dissolute and imprudent that which his prudent and virtuous neighbour in the adjoining room is unable to purchase. The Visitor’s ticket for bread and coals renders this unworthy fellow’s income for the week far better than that of the industrious, independent, high-minded man who is bravely struggling against his difficulties on the other side of the partition which divides their rooms; and alms, so given, operate, to all intents and purposes, as a premium on vice and a great discouragement to virtue.
“I cannot, my Lord, help thinking that the experience of Mr. J. K. Barker might be very advantageously taken as a guide to the District Visitor on such an occasion. This gentleman had been most kindly active in the administration of the parochial affairs of Hambledon. He says:* ‘There were two labourers who were reported to me as extremely industrious men, maintaining large families. Neither of them had ever applied for parish relief. I thought it advisable that they should receive some mark of public approbation; and we gave them one pound apiece from the parish. Very shortly after this, they both became applicants for relief, and have continued so ever since. I am not aware that any other cause existed for this change in the con-
* “Administration of the Poor Laws,” page 85. |
OF GRATUITOUS ASSISTANCE. | 223 |
“Nothing can permanently better the condition of the working classes but an increase of prudence.” The Visiting Society has a direct tendency to destroy the exercise of this virtue. In addressing the labouring classes, it takes the care of themselves out of their own hands. Were the father of a family to say, ‘If, my lads, you are in any difficulty about paying your bills at Christmas, never mind, come to me, I’ll settle them for you,’ does not your Lordship think he would very soon find his lads always in difficulty about their Christmas bills, and that he would have more presented than he could conveniently pay? The case is precisely the same with Relief Societies. The effect which they have upon the poor population of a parish cannot be better illustrated than by an anecdote related by Thomas Walker, the late excellent Police Magistrate: ‘The founder of Guy’s Hospital left to the Trustees a fund to be distributed to such of his relations as should, from time to time, fall into distress. The fund, at length, became insufficient to meet the applications; and the Trustees, thinking it hard to refuse any claimants, trenched upon the funds of the Hospital; the consequence of which was that no Guy was ever known to prosper. So that if any individual
224 | LAWS OF PROV1DENCE. |
“Just so is it with all these public charities for the poor. Like Guy’s fund, they set before the eyes of the labouring classes an inducement to distress; and those classes will never prosper till such ill-judging friends as the ‘Metropolitan District Visiting and Relief Association’ can be persuaded to withdraw their pernicious protection from them. All these newly-invented benevolent Institutions, which are formed to help the poor through every difficulty of life, are framed in direct opposition to the counsels of Providence; for all those difficulties were designed by the Almighty as a part of a wise but severe discipline, to compel us to look beyond the present and provide for the future, by suffering from the idleness or imprudence of the past.
“Whenever we attempt to amend the scheme of Providence and to interfere with the government of the world, we had need to be very circumspect, lest we do more harm than good. In New England, they once thought blackbirds useless and mischievous to the corn; and they made efforts to destroy them. The consequence was the blackbirds were diminished; but a kind of worm which devoured their grass, and which the black-
TRUCK CHARITY. | 225 |
With reference to giving relief in kind instead of money, Mr. Harness adds: “A poor person will always make a shilling purchase twice as much again as a rich one will do for him. As one out of many cases which I could cite in proof of this, I will extract from the Journal of a Clergyman (who, by-the-by, is a London Curate of eighteen years’ standing, and identifies himself in all my views) what was done by one of his poor with the small sum of sixpence farthing:
1lb. of meat | 2½ |
½lb of flour | 1¼ |
—— | |
Carried forward | 3¾ |
* A letter of Franklin’s, preserved in “The Diary of a Lover of Literature.” See Gentleman’s Magazine, New Series, Vol. I., page 12. |
226 | A Clergyman's Journal. |
Brought forward | 3¾ |
71bs. of coals | 1¼ |
Carrots | ½ |
Potatoes | ½ |
Turnips | ¼ |
“Besides, under this system of truck charity, how do we know that the visitor will always have the discretion to adjust properly the sort of relief which is required by the nature of the necessity? As an example of the egregious blunders committed in this way, we must give another extract from the Journal of our clerical friend: ‘Went to see Mrs. Cole.
A CLERGYMAN'S JOURNAL. | 227 |
“Again (I copy the words of the journal): ‘There is no creature in the world so hard-hearted as the woman who makes charity her business. This morning’s scene has annoyed and grieved me very much. I called on poor Mrs. Smart. She cannot have more than a day or two to live. The poor creature was, as usual, on the three chairs placed together, which form her only bed; but sitting up, and in a state of frightful nervous agitation. Her hands were clasped and pressed tight against her breast. She was rocking herself backward and forward as violently as her weakness would allow, and repeating with continually increased rapidity of utterance, till the words became confounded and were scarcely distinguishable, “Oh! Lord! take away my heart of stone, and give me a
228 | A CLERGYMAN'S JOURNAL. |
“On my entering the room, the Visitor noticed me with that air of formal and supercilious distance which party-spirited ladies are apt to exhibit towards those of the clergy whom they condemn as not sufficiently spiritual in their views. Pointing to the dying creature, she said: “A sad sight, Sir! A miserable end! No hope, I fear, here?” “Why, what has happened? There was none of this excitement when I left this morning.” “The heart of stone! The heart of stone! No answer to her prayers! No fruit of the Spirit! No joy!” “Oh! Madam! why do you pass so severe a sentence on our poor sister?” “Can you consider this anything but a state of reprobation? Where is the heart of flesh? Where is the joy?” “Joy! Madam!” “What! do you mean to assert, Sir, that joy is not an indispensable fruit of the Spirit?” “This is really no place or time for religious
A CLERGYMAN'S JOURNAL. | 229 |
“As soon as the visiting lady left us, I sat down on a box beside poor, ignorant, inoffensive Mrs. Smart, and did my best to tranquillize her. I first induced her to stop the quick, anxious, hysterical repetition of the words which had been put into her mouth. When I had succeeded in this, and she became composed, I explained the nature both of “a heart of stone” and “a heart of flesh.” I showed her that the one signified a state of mind which was insensible to all religious impressions; the other, a state of mind which was open to such impressions. I, by my questions, led her back, through a calm course of self-examination on these important subjects, to the hopeful reliance on God’s mercy through Christ, which she had enjoyed in my previous visits; and then, after reading some prayers from the Visitation Service, I took my leave of her for to-day’.”
Mr. Harness proceeds to suggest that, instead of
230 | LAY-READERS. |
“By far the most creditable specimen of this class whom I have known employed in that part of London where I reside, was an Irishman, and not wanting in those gifts of fluency and quickness which are common to his nation. By trade he was a journeyman house-painter; but he had a spirit which disdained the fustian jacket and the paper cap. He cast about for some less humble and more lucrative mode of life; and, after absenting himself for a few weeks, he returned among us, in a full suit of mourning, and sent circulars round the neighbourhood to inform all those who were willing to trust their teeth in his hands, that he was practising as a ‘surgeon-dentist.’ This business he did not pursue for a much longer period than he had devoted to acquiring the knowledge of it.
“Not meeting with the success he had anticipated
* He proposed as a substitute to admit to Holy Orders men “who had retired from their profession or business, and desired to dedicate the remainder of their days to the service of God and the succour of His creatures.” |
LAY-READERS. | 231 |
The pamphlet from which the above extracts are taken was a development of an article which Mr. Harness had sent to Mr. Lockhart for insertion in
232 | REPLY OF MR. LOCKHART. |
“I have read your MS. It is exceedingly able—most effective—most capital, in short; and I have no doubt you are right in the main.
“I don’t doubt, however, that good has been and is daily done by the sort of Societies you are attacking, and I could not publish the article without several interpolations.
“But I couldn’t, were it one chrysolite, accept it for this number. I told you truly—I am full. I publish this month, and no article ever has much chance unless it comes to hand at a much earlier stage of my operations.
“I am sorry indeed, but can’t help this. I see you are in a hurry, and no wonder; for really much of it is as good as anything Sydney Smith ever wrote.
On receiving the above letter, Mr. Harness published a considerable part of this article in the Times; and it was so well received that the editor wrote to him requesting further communications on the subject.
PAROCHIAL LABOURS. | 233 |
The year after this pamphlet appeared, Mr. Harness left St. Pancras. More than one reason induced him to seek a change. Twenty years of unremitting labour in a metropolitan district, which had meanwhile increased from 16,000 to 23,000, had rendered him less capable of bodily exertion; and an accident which had befallen him on a summer excursion, made his parochial duties more laborious to him. Notwithstanding his lameness from infancy—which always caused him more or less pain in walking—Mr. Harness was an active pedestrian, sometimes accomplishing as much as thirty miles in one day; and when on a tour in Wales, about ten years before this date, as he was descending a hill with a heavy knapsack on his back, his knee suddenly gave way, and he found that he had fractured the knee-pan. After this accident, he was always in danger of falling; he required the assistance of a stick; and the mounting steep and narrow stair-cases became a matter of difficulty, if not of danger, to him. To these reasons for resigning his London cure, we should add that he always loved the country, and now became unusually weary of his long confinement to town.
In a letter to Miss Mitford, written at this time, he thus expresses his feelings:—
“I wish I could get to Reading to visit you;
234 | LONGING FOR THE COUNTRY. |
Mr. Harness thought that now, in his fifty-fourth year, he might very suitably retire and accept a less onerous sphere of usefulness. He was never an ambitious man, and rather avoided than courted public commendation. But he loved those among whom he had laboured during the Spring and Summer-tide of his life, and was deeply touched at the concern they manifested on his departure; and in his farewell address he confessed that he should not even then have negotiated for an exchange, had he not been suffering from “some unaccountable languor and depression of spirits.” It was then too late for him to alter his determination; but his parishioners, in memory of his long and faithful ministry among them, subscribed for a
* Mecklenburgh Square. He then lived in Heathcote Street, just out of the Square. |
UNFORTUNATE EXCHANGE. | 235 |
The change proved truly unfortunate. Although Mr. Harness had constantly moved in what is called “the world” (it was his pride to say that he associated with all classes, from the highest to the lowest), there never was a man less imbued with its maxims, or less animated by its spirit. Generous and unsuspicious to a fault, he attributed to others the high motives by which he was himself actuated. As a consequence he was, therefore, generally unfortunate in business transactions; even to such an extent that his income would have been considerably diminished, had it not been from time to time unexpectedly supplemented by legacies from friends and strangers. In the present instance, without instituting the necessary inquiries, he accepted a retired living, in place of his London incumbency; and when he came to take possession of his rural retreat, he found to his cost that justice had now deserted not only the town, but also the country. The church and parsonage had been allowed to fall completely out of repair; and as he would have been personally liable for dilapidations, he finally resolved to adopt the advice of a friend and not to enter into possession.
Having thus lost his position, he was obliged to
* A massive silver candelebrum. |
236 | BROMPTON CHAPEL. |
≪ PREV | NEXT ≫ |